Credible Theories

Pliny's Burning Shield: The Sparking Object Over Rome in 100 BCE

Pliny the Elder records a burning, sparking shield that crossed the sky at sunset from west to east in 100 BCE.

Pliny the Elder's Natural History records that in 100 BCE a burning shield, scattering sparks, ran across the sky at sunset from west to east. Astronomers say it fits a bright fireball meteor.

TraditionGreece and Rome
WhenEvent 100 BCE; Pliny wrote c. 77 CE
Also calledburning shield, clipeus ardens, burning shields

Pliny the Elder's Natural History, finished around 77 CE, is an encyclopedia of everything the Romans knew about the world. Book 2 covers the heavens and the weather, including comets, meteors and other lights seen in the sky. One short entry has become famous. Pliny collected reports from hundreds of earlier authors, and he often names the year an event occurred.

In the Bostock and Riley translation: "In the consulship of Lucius Valerius and Caius Marius, a burning shield, scattering sparks, was seen to run across the heavens, at sunset, from west to east." Romans dated years by their two consuls, and Lucius Valerius Flaccus served with Gaius Marius in Marius's sixth consulship, which places the sighting in 100 BCE.

Pliny files the event among other named phenomena: beams of light, torches, and burning shields (clipei ardentes) were categories in ancient weather lore, much as modern observers classify fireballs and bolides. In the same part of his work he reports blood-red skies, stones falling from heaven and several suns seen at once.

For UFO writers the attraction is the specificity: shape, color, sparks, time of day, direction of travel and a firm year. Astronomers note that the description fits a bright fireball, a meteor that breaks up and leaves sparks as it crosses the sky. The west-to-east path at sunset is not unusual for such an object. What remains striking is how carefully the Romans logged it.

Strangest fact

The sighting can be dated to a single year because it is anchored to the consulship of Gaius Marius, one of the most famous Romans of his age.

What a skeptic would say

A burning, sparking round object crossing the sky is a good description of a fireball meteor, and Pliny himself treats burning shields as a known class of natural sky-sign.

Questions people ask about Pliny's burning shield

What did Pliny the Elder see in the sky?

Pliny did not see it himself; he collected reports. In the Bostock and Riley translation: "In the consulship of Lucius Valerius and Caius Marius, a burning shield, scattering sparks, was seen to run across the heavens, at sunset, from west to east."

When was the burning shield seen?

Romans dated years by their two consuls, and Pliny anchors the sighting to the consulship of Lucius Valerius and Caius Marius. Lucius Valerius Flaccus served with Gaius Marius in Marius's sixth consulship, which places the burning shield in 100 BCE.

What was Pliny's burning shield?

Astronomers note the description fits a bright fireball, a meteor that breaks up and leaves sparks. Pliny himself filed burning shields (clipei ardentes) as a known class of sky-sign, alongside beams and torches, much as modern observers classify fireballs and bolides.

Where it turns up

Sources

  1. Pliny the Elder, Natural History 2.34, trans. John Bostock and H. T. Riley (1855)Primary text
  2. Wikipedia, "Natural History (Pliny)"Reference
  3. Wikipedia, "Bolide"Reference

Quotations come from public-domain translations. Links open the free online copy or the reference page.

Updated